Page 1 of 1

Fuzzy logic, SD, and Business Policies

Posted: Tue Dec 14, 2004 7:42 pm
by jnoble1@mmm.com
I would like to query the list on who is doing research in integrating
fuzzy logic and system dynamics for business management problems and
what's been recently published on the topic. A brief search of ""System
Dynamics Review"" for the past 5 years or so did not turn anything up. Here
is my motivation for asking the question. One of the pillars of SD is the
constant emphasis on transparency and ""understandability"" of the models
created for the clients and customers of a particular SD project. It seems
to me that fuzzy logic, with it's capability to quantify and execute
inferences with qualitative categories of phenomena, would be a beautiful
complement to traditional SD methods and goals. This would be especially
true around business policy issues, where I would think an interactive
formulation process with clients around capturing business rules using
qualitative words and in ""If-then"" relationships would be especially
helpful in making connections between abstract model constructs and actual
operating procedures, For example, a set of business rules in
manufacturing planning interrelating variables such as demand, order
back-log, and capacity rate changes could have appropriate states and
trajectories mapped to membership functions and then formulated as rules
such as the following: ""If demand is increasing rapidly and the order
back-log is large, a large increase in capacity is expedited"". A set of
such rules would seem to be 1.) much more intuitive than equations and
mathematical formulations and 2.) allow for nonlinear formulations as
typically occur in policies of any complexity. When trying to ""tune"" a
model with historical time series data, recent work in fuzzy modeling to
capture quantitative relationships with a minimum number of rules to
improve ""interpretability"" would seem to be very helpful for this
application. I just would like to know if anyone in the SD community has
been going down this path of research and what conclusions they have been
reaching.
Thanks,

Jonathan Noble
3M Supply Chain
ph. 641-828-5518
Tri: 828-5518
e-mail: jnoble1@mmm.com

Fuzzy logic, SD, and Business Policies

Posted: Wed Dec 15, 2004 7:43 pm
by Joel Rahn
A fuzzy relation between two variables can be de-fuzzified to make a
LOOKUP function Vensim (formerly TABLE function in DYNAMO) and a LOOKUP
function can represent a fuzzy relation between two variables. The whole
argument rests on a representation theorem for fuzzy relations that
says, essentially, a fuzzy relation can represent a piece-wise
approximation of an arbitrary function -i.e. an arbitrary LOOKUP
function. Going from a LOOKUP function to a useful fuzzy relation is
trickier -the membership functions seem to be constrained to be
triangular to make the fuzzification straightforward but the result may
not be intuitive; for example, there may be 'too many' triangular
membership functions as in Hot, Medium Hot, Warm, Medium Warm, Tepid,
Medium Tepid,..,..,..,..,Cold.

Joel Rahn
jrahn@sympatico.ca

Fuzzy logic, SD, and Business Policies

Posted: Wed Dec 15, 2004 10:57 pm
by John Gunkler
Granted, it's been awhile since I used fuzzy logic -- but as I recall, some
of the best ways to represent fuzzy logic involved the use of graphs.
Doesn't using non-linear graphical functions to represent relationships in
our models pretty much accomplish what fuzzy logic tries to do?

From: ""John Gunkler"" <jgunkler@sprintmail.com>

Fuzzy logic, SD, and Business Policies

Posted: Thu Dec 23, 2004 12:18 am
by Ignacio J Martinez-Moyano
Jonathan,

you could take a look at:

Tessem, B. and P. I. Davidsen (1994). ""Fuzzy System Dynamics: An Approach to Vague and Qualitative Variables in Simulation."" System Dynamics Review 10(1): 49-62.

This is one reference from the Review that deals with the relationship between fuzzy logic and system dynamics.

Best,

Nacho
__________________________
Ignacio J Martinez-Moyano
Center for Policy Research
System Dynamics Group
University at Albany
Albany, New York
(518) 442-3859
im7797@albany.edu