Errors with WITH LOOK UP function

[ngtrang]

Could you tell me if there is any error related to missed parens in the following equation? I tried but could not fix it.
Thank you.

Cost of waste recycling = Transportation cost+WITH LOOKUP(maturation of waste recycling market, ((0.15,40),(0.2,35),(0.3,30),(0.4,27),(0.5,23),(0.6,18),(0.7,16),(0.8,14)))

The Vensim notified about an error with Lookup function: look for missing parens

[tomfid]

I think the error message may be misleading. WITH LOOKUP has to be the first & only thing on the right side of the equation - that's probably the issue here.

[ngtrang]

I think the error message may be misleading. WITH LOOKUP has to be the first & only thing on the right side of the equation - that's probably the issue here.

Thank you so much, I understood the issue here.
What other function can I use in case I want to calculate the total cost as equal to transportation cost plus recycling cost (for example) which in turn depends on the maturation of the market? I mean a combined functions like the inital idea.

[Administrator]

What other function can I use in case I want to calculate the total cost as equal to transportation cost plus recycling cost (for example) which in turn depends on the maturation of the market? I mean a combined functions like the inital idea.

It's probably best if you start a new topic and provide more details.

[tomfid]

Just create a separate variable.

z = x + y
y = WITH LOOKUP(...)

[tomfid]

Or use an ordinary lookup variable instead of WITH LOOKUP:

z = x + y( input )
y = (0,1),(1,2),(3,4), ...

[ngtrang]

Or use an ordinary lookup variable instead of WITH LOOKUP:

z = x + y( input )
y = (0,1),(1,2),(3,4), ...

Thank you

[ngtrang]

Just create a separate variable.

z = x + y
y = WITH LOOKUP(...)

Thank you. I am trying to re-establish the model found from a published paper to understand the methodology. The authors explained a formula in which x = a + WITH LOOKUP (y). Then I tried doing similar things but now I know WITH LOOKUP can not be used in such a combination like this.

[Administrator]

I always discourage the use of WITH LOOKUP, I'm not sure why anyone uses it. It much better to define the lookup as a separate variable.

[tomfid]

I don't discourage it, but I tend to use regular lookups in my own work. WITH LOOKUP is fine if you'll only use the curve shape once.

I'm puzzled that the authors describe x = a + WITH LOOKUP (y) - that hasn't ever worked, and the function is more or less unique to Vensim. Perhaps it was simply a shorthand.

[domenicacox36]

Hi, i am also have issues with creating LOOKUP functions in Venism PLE. I am trying to create a look up function for the impact of a policy throughout time (2024-2050) so that i can use it to show that the policy will have a non-linear impact on other variables in my model depending on the year. However, when I create an auxillary variable and use the =WITHLOOKUP (ImpactLSP([(2024, 0)-(2050, 1)],(2024, 0.3),(2025,0.35),(2026,0.4)
(2027, 0.2), (2028,0.19),(2029, 0.1)). I am getting the error "expecting an operator". Do you know why this might be. Any help would be really appreciated.